A Question Of Flushability: Wet Wipes Swirl Down The Drain And End Up In Federal Court

Oct 25, 2017
Originally published on October 30, 2017 9:15 am

In the last decade, a multibillion-dollar industry has emerged - and much of its products end up in our toilets. We’re talking about the wet wipes industry. 

Companies that once just made baby wipes, like Irving-based Kimberly-Clark Corporation, now sell wet wipes in all shapes and sizes, for all ages, and some are categorized as "flushable." As soon as those wipes go down the drain, though, controversy bubbles up.

The 'rag' issue


The odor at the Trinity River Authority's Wastewater Treatment Plant in West Dallas is pungent; more than 100 million gallons of raw sewage pass through here each day. Technical Services Manager Bill Cyrus is wearing a yellow safety vest, a hard hat and a bushy salt-and-pepper mustache.


He doesn’t even flinch at the smell.

 


This plant is the first stop for much of Dallas’ wastewater, where all the solids that didn’t break down in the pipes are removed with bars and screens. These days, the screens are filled not only with paper towels and feminine hygiene products, but increasingly, wet wipes. Cyrus calls the mucky, off-white and gray material “rags.”


“The rag issue [has] gone up exponentially over the last five to six years,” he said.


When the rags build up, they can damage the machinery, plug pumps and back up the entire system, all the way back to your bathroom. Cyrus said maintenance like “de-ragging” and hauling the waste to the landfill cost $165,000 in 2015.


“It's costing [the public] more to treat their wastewater. It’s tearing up equipment [and] costing a lot more manpower when they could just be throwing it in the trash can in the first place,” he said. “You know, out of sight, out of mind.”


Fatbergs form


Convenience is a big reason we’ve gone crazy for wet wipes, said Jennifer Christ with the U.S. market research firm Freedonia Group.


“The wet wipes industry has grown from being baby wipes and wipes to clean your hands after eating ribs to a $2.1-billion industry,” she said.


There’s a wipe for everything: to clean grease, to remove makeup and to apply deodorant, insect repellent and sunscreen. Even investor Mark Cuban got in on the wipes business after a pitch from the founders of Dude Wipes on “Shark Tank.”

 


Wastewater managers across the globe say flushing so many wipes has a disgusting side effect: Fatbergs. Those are massive globs (sometimes the size of double-decker buses) of congealed cooking fat, held together with the help of wet wipes. The largest fatbergs were found in London’s sewers, but they’re forming in the U.S., too. Recently Baltimore utility workers had to use water jets and a slicing device to scrape away a fatberg there.


The National Association of Clean Water Agencies says wipes are jamming pumps — even the supposedly flushable ones — costing U.S. utilities up to $1 billion a year. But the Association of Nonwoven Fabric Industries, which represents the makers of wet wipes, says wipes labeled "flushable" go through testing and are compatible with wastewater systems. So, what’s the deal?


“The industry has had a really hard time defining what it means to be 'flushable,'” Jennifer Christ said.


Legality of labels


Now, the question of flushability will go to federal court. This month, Irving-based wet wipe maker Kimberly-Clark sued Washington D.C. after the district created its own flushability standards. Note: Kimberly-Clark is a sponsor of KERA.


The corporation alleges, among other things, that the new law could require companies to label products “do not flush,” and doing so would violate the First Amendment.


Yes, there will be a debate over wet wipes, labeling and the U.S. Constitution.

Trina McCormick directs research and engineering for Kimberly-Clark’s Family Care business, which includes Cottonelle flushable wipes.

“Honestly, non-flushable wipes are causing a lot of the problems, non-flushables and trash,” McCormick said.

She points out that wipes labeled “flushable” already meet the industry-set standards. Among the seven tests of flushability is the “slosh box test” to see if a wipe breaks down while being agitated.

Mary Gugliuzza with the Fort Worth Water Department says the standards aren’t good enough.

“Companies labeling them as ‘flushable’ aren’t the ones having to deal with the sewer system. Just because something can be flushed doesn’t mean it should be flushed,” Gugliuzza said.


One of the challenges is identifying which wipes are causing problems. It’s a nasty job Bill Cyrus back at the water treatment plant in Dallas is digging into. He’s looking at used wet wipes removed from the sewer, trying to figure out which brands are clogging the system.


He says he’s not anti-wet wipes. But if you choose to use them, he says, at least for now, please put them in the trash. 


Copyright 2017 KERA. To see more, visit KERA.